Layered cornices and brick rooflines of New York apartment buildings at November dusk, with a few warmly lit windows and sparse autumn leaves.

Fannie Mae Says It's Still Lending on Rent-Stabilized Buildings. For a Portfolio Seller, the Real Question Is How Much.

"It is false to report Freddie Mac has frozen lending on those properties in NYC, and in fact we continue to quote and lend on those properties." FHFA Director Bill Pulte posted that on November 2, 2026, hours after The City Reporter reported a pause. The Fiscal Policy Institute quotes the post in full.

Earlier that day, Rafael Cestero, CEO of the Community Preservation Corp., described the new assumptions this way to The City Reporter: "underwriting anything other than operating in a rent-freeze environment wouldn't really be factually accurate."

Both statements can hold at once. A lender can keep quoting loans while each quote gets smaller.

The Loan Shrinks Before Anyone Says No

According to The City Reporter, Fannie Mae's revised underwriting for NYC rent-regulated buildings assumes no increase in stabilized rents for four to eight years. That window covers Mayor Zohran Mamdani's current term and a possible second one. Fannie and lenders like CPC also assume operating expenses rise at least 5% a year. CPC doubled its expected collection loss to 10%. Fannie did not respond to the outlet's request for comment, and the account rests on landlords, advocates and nonprofit executives who spoke on background.

Each assumption lowers underwritten net operating income in its own way.

  • Revenue is held flat. Stabilized income stays at today's level for the whole underwriting period.
  • Expenses compound. At 5% a year, the expense line is about 22% higher after four years and about 48% higher after eight.
  • Collections are haircut harder. A 10% loss assumption takes another slice off income that is already flat.

The underwritten NOI is the basis for the loan amount. The Real Deal summarized what happens next: lower projected income and higher expenses reduce what lenders will advance, and tighter loan-to-value limits mean owners have to bring more equity.

Rates make it worse. Cestero told The City Reporter: "It's one thing to have a freeze when interest rates are at 3%. It's another when they are at 7%." The 10-year Treasury stood at 4.861% on November 6, 2026. General agency pricing guidance dated November 1 put Fannie's conventional 10-year loans at 6.00% to 6.20% at 55% LTV with a 1.55 debt service coverage ratio. That guidance is not a term sheet for NYC rent-regulated buildings.

The Discount Is Already in Per-Unit Pricing

The market priced regulation before the November reports came out. In Q3 2026, buildings at least 50% rent-stabilized made up 51.7% of NYC multifamily transactions but only 23.0% of dollar volume. Year to date, these buildings totaled $1.27 billion across 146 trades. Average per-unit prices over the trailing six months through Q3 2026 show how far apart the tiers sit:

Submarket Lower-regulation tier 75%+ rent-stabilized
Bronx $217K/unit, free market incl. 421a $68K/unit
Brooklyn $244K/unit, 50–75% stabilized $134K/unit
Manhattan below 96th St. $207K/unit, 50–75% stabilized $156K/unit
Northern Manhattan $150K/unit, 50–75% stabilized $119K/unit
Queens No 50–75% sales reported $155K/unit

In the Bronx, 75%+ stabilized buildings accounted for 81.3% of the borough's multifamily dollar volume in Q3. The quarter's largest Bronx portfolio trade fits the pattern. Arena Real Estate's predominantly rent-stabilized Fordham portfolio, 306 units and 271,011 gross square feet, sold for $15.0 million on July 21, 2026, about $49,000 a unit. In Inwood, the predominantly stabilized Miller & Miller portfolio sold for $23.5 million on September 15, 2026.

These trades closed before the new underwriting assumptions were reported.

The Buyer Pool Is Sorted by Leverage

This is where the financing squeeze becomes a question of who can buy. Lending on NYC buildings with at least half their units regulated fell from $27.6 billion across more than 3,700 loans in 2019 to under $11.3 billion across roughly 1,400 loans in 2025, CRE Daily reported, citing Atrium Data figures published by Bisnow. The agencies' share of those originations rose from 4% in 2019 to nearly 15% in 2024, then eased to 9% in 2025. After Signature Bank failed and New York Community Bank left the business, Fannie and Freddie became what The Real Deal called lenders of last resort for the sector.

The Real Deal reported that mixed-income properties are comparatively insulated by market-rate rents.

CPC's April report found 12% delinquency in December across the Signature-linked portfolio it services, up from 10% in 2024.

The Fiscal Policy Institute argues that the freeze is not the main cause of stress in stabilized buildings. It points instead to years of agency lending to high-risk buildings at high rates.

The Rent Freeze

The freeze is in force. Under the Rent Guidelines Board order, it applies to stabilized leases that take effect on or after October 1, 2026. As of The Real Deal's October 1 report, Judge Brendan Lantry had declined to halt it while the landlords' lawsuit proceeds.

FAQ

Is Freddie Mac lending on NYC rent-stabilized buildings? The City Reporter reported a pause, citing several real estate sources. FHFA Director Bill Pulte said Freddie continues to quote and lend on these properties. Freddie's own statement said it "continuously reviews market conditions and makes real-time adjustments."

Does this affect buildings with market-rate units? Less. The Real Deal and The City Reporter both describe mixed-income properties as comparatively insulated, because market-rate rents have risen sharply. Market-rate rents rose 4.3% year over year through September, according to Chandan Economics data cited by CRE Daily.

Is nonprofit capital an alternative buyer pool? It is under strain too. Cestero said CPC expects to make 50% fewer loans to all-affordable projects in New York City than it did two years ago.

This post is general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm any financing or contract decision with your own attorney, lender or tax advisor.

Exodus Capital runs disciplined, discreet portfolio sales built around buyers who can close at today's debt levels. Discuss your exit strategy.

Work With Exodus

Receive Market Updates

Follow Me on Instagram